"ONLY THE USSR HAVE"CLEAN HANDS": THE USSR, COLLECTIVE SECURITY IN EUROPE AND DESTINY OF CZECHOSLOVAKIA (1934-1938)
Table of contents
Share
QR
Metrics
"ONLY THE USSR HAVE"CLEAN HANDS": THE USSR, COLLECTIVE SECURITY IN EUROPE AND DESTINY OF CZECHOSLOVAKIA (1934-1938)
Annotation
PII
S013038640000616-5-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Edition
Pages
44-81
Abstract
In the article based on an extensive archival material is shown the escalation of Czechoslovakian crisis, which has led to the Munich pact 1938. The author in details shines the position of the USSR, in particular, the Litvinovs role in occurring events, and also behavior of the western states, not wished to protect Czechoslovakia from claims from outside the Third Reich.
Keywords
MUNICH CRISIS, CZECHOSLOVAKIA, DALADIER, CHAMBERLAIN, COLLECTIVE SECURITY, BENEš, M.M. LITVINOV, POLICY OF APPEASEMENT
Date of publication
01.01.2012
Number of purchasers
1
Views
1154
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite   Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials

  1. Galifaks -britanskoj delegatsii v Zheneve, № 54, 23 sentyabrya 1938. -Documents of British Foreign Policy (dalee: DBFP), ser. 3. London, 1949-1957, v. II, p. 480; Majskij I.M. Dnevnik diplomata (dalee: Dnevnik). M., 2006, kn. 1, s. 277-280.
  2. Young R.J. France and the Origins of the Second World War. New York, 1996; Parker R.A.C. Chamberlain and Appeasement: British Policy and the Coming of the Second World War. London, 1993; Carley M.J. 1939: The Alliance That Never Was and the Coming of World War II. Chicago, 1999.
  3. Pons S. Stalin and the Inevitable War, 1936-1941. London -Portland, 2002, p. 126 i dalee.
  4. Steiner Z. The Soviet Commissariat of Foreign Affairs and the Czechoslovakian Crisis in 1938: New Material from the Soviet Archives. -Historical Journal, № 42 (1999), p. 751-779.
  5. Ragsdale H. The Soviets, the Munich Crisis, and the Coming of World War II. London -New York, 2004.              
  6. Sipols V.Ya. Sovetskij Soyuz v bor'be za mir i bezopasnost' 1933-1939. M., 1974.
  7. Volkov V.K. Myunkhenskij sgovor i balkanskie strany. M., 1978.    
  8. Sevost'yanov G.N. Evropejskij krizis i pozitsiya SShA, 1938-1939. M., 1992, s. 108-110.
  9. Chelyshev I.A. SSSR -Frantsiya: trudnye gody, 1938-1941. M., 1999, s. 41.
  10. Orlik I.I. Ehduard Benesh: gody pobed i porazhenij. -Novaya i novejshaya istoriya. 2008, № 5, s. 150-152.                  
  11. Bezymenskij L.A. Stalin i Gitler pered skhvatkoj. M., 2009, s. 140-151.
  12. Khristoforov V.S. Myunkhenskoe soglashenie -prolog Vtoroj mirovoj vojny (po arkhivnym materialam FSB Rossii) -Novaya i novejshaya istoriya. 2009, № 1, s. 21-47.        
  13. Mar'ina V.V. Esche raz o Myunkhene (novye dokumenty cheshskikh arkhivov). -Vojna. Narod. Pobeda. M., 2008, s. 19-59.
  14. Sluch S.Z. Sovetskij Soyuz i chekhoslovatskij krizis 1938 goda. Nekotorye aspekty politiki nevmeshatel'stva. -Myunkhenskoe soglashenie 1938 goda: istoriya i sovremennost'. M., 2009, s. 114-144.
  15. Novye dokumenty iz istorii Myunkhena. M., 1958; Dokumenty vneshnej politiki SSSR (dalee -DVP), t. XXI. M., 1977; Dokumenty i materialy kanuna Vtoroj mirovoj vojny, t. 1. M., 1981; Dokumenty po istorii myunkhenskogo sgovora (dalee -DIMS). M., 1979; Dokumenty i materialy po istorii sovetsko-chekhoslovatskikh otnoshenij, t. 3. M., 1978; Documents on German Foreign Policy (dalee -DGFP), ser. C, v. 4. Washington, 1962; Foreign Relations of the United States, 1938 (dalee: FRUS, 1938), v. I-II Washington, 1955; Documents diplomatiques francais (dalee -DDF), 1re serie, t. VII. Paris, 1964-1984 etc.
  16. Charles Alphand, Frantsuzskij posol v Moskve, nos. 444-446, 12 octobre 1934. -DDF, 1re serie. Paris, 1964-1984, v. VII, p. 718-719; Arkhiv vneshnej politiki Rossijskoj Federatsii (dalee: AVP RF), f. 0136, op. 19, p. 164, d. 814, l. 166-170.
  17. MAE [Ministere des Affaires etrangeres, Paris], [ancienne serie Z] Europe, 1918-1940, URSS, v. 974, fol. 26.
  18. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 15, p. 113, d. 122, l. 150-151; Politbyuro TsK RKP(b) -VKP(b) i Evropa. Resheniya "osoboj papki", 1923-1939. M., 2001, s. 322.
  19. AVP RF, f. 082, op. 18, p. 80, d. 1, l. 49-52.
  20. DVP, t. XVIII, s. 292-293, 295-296.
  21. DVP, t. XVIII, s. 296-297; Politbyuro TsK RKP(b), s. 325, 326.
  22. DDF, 1er, t. X, r. 384-385.
  23. DVP, t. XIV, s. 306-309.
  24. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 15, p. 113, d. 122, l. 179-182; p. 106, d. 16, l. 5-6; Na prieme u Stalina: tetradi (zhurnaly) zapisej lits, prinimaemykh I.V. Stalinym (1924-1953 gg.). M., 2008, s. 160-161.
  25. Dokumenty i materialy po istorii sovetsko-chekhoslovatskikh otnoshenij v 5 tomakh. M., 1973-1975, t. III, s. 106-107.
  26. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 15, p. 113, l. 184; DDF, 1er, X, 361-362; AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 19, p. 164, d. 814, l. 106.
  27. Politbyuro TsK RKP(b), s. 326.
  28. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 15, p. 113, d. 122, l. 163-166.
  29. Sovetsko-rumynskie otnosheniya: dokumenty i materialy (dalee: SRO). M., 2000, t. II, s. 18-19, 21-22; AVP RF, f. 0138, op. 16, p. 122-a, d. 1, l. 30-31.
  30. SRO, t. II, s. 24-25; AVP RF, f. 082, op. 18, p. 80, d. 1, l. 69-71.
  31. SRO, t. II, s. 30-33, 39-44; AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 19, p. 164, d. 814, l. 74-77.
  32. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 19, p. 164, d. 814, l. 96-99.
  33. MAE URSS/977, ff. 175-176.
  34. Sargent's minute, 4 May 1935, C3613/55/18, FO [National Archives of the United Kingdom, Kew, Foreign Offi ce] 371 18838.
  35. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 19, p. 164, d. 814, l. 106; MAE URSS/973, ff. 107-110; ibid. URSS/1004, ff. 172-174.
  36. Telegramma frantsuzskogo posla v Londone Sharlya Korbena № 110 ot 8 fevralya 1935 g. (MAE URSS/972, ff. 116-119).
  37. Tabouis G. They Called Me Cassandra. New York, 1942, r. 207.
  38. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 14, p. 95, d. 4, l. 53-63; op. 15, p. 103, d. 1, l. 3-8, 65-67.
  39. AVP RF, f. 082, op. 15, p. 80, d. 1, l. 67-68.
  40. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 15, p. 106, d. 30, l. 15-16.
  41. Sargent's minutes, 19 Feb. & 3 June 1935, C1339/55/18, FO 371 18826; C4694/55/18, FO 371 18846.
  42. N6304/135/38, FO 371 19460.
  43. MAE URSS/978, ff. 195-197; AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 19, p. 164, d. 814, l. 133-141.
  44. AVP RF, op. 19, p. 164, l. 7-13, 17-18; op. 16, p. 154, d. 730, l. 13-15.
  45. N2418/22/38, FO 371 16319.
  46. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 6, d. 89, p. 21, l. 7-12; Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj arkhiv sotsial'no-politicheskoj istorii, f. 359, op. 1, d. 7, l. 95; AVP RF, f. 05, op. 15, p. 113, d. 122, l. 110; N1404/75/38, FO 371 14860; C4517/18/17, FO 371 20686; Stalin's Letters to Molotov, 1925-1936. New Haven, 1995, p. 174-175.
  47. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 20, p. 167, d. 828, l. 11-27.
  48. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 15, p. 106, d. 16, l. 35-37; SRO, t. II, s. 34-38.
  49. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 19, p. 164, d. 814, l. 2-3, 4-6.
  50. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 15, p. 106, d. 30, l. 33; f. 082, op. 18, p. 80, d. 1, l. 100-101.
  51. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 19, d. 814, p. 164, l. 119-122; DGFP, ser. C, v. 4, r. 255-256, 493-496, 925-926.
  52. SRO, t. II, s. 58-59; Robert Coulondre, frantsuzskij posol v Moskve, no. 20, 8 janv. 1937, MAE, Bureau du chiffre, telegrammes a l'arrivee de Moscou, 1937.
  53. Sovetsko-amerikanskie otnosheniya: gody nepriznaniya, 1927-1933. M., 2002, s. 748-749.
  54. Sovetsko-amerikanskie otnosheniya, 1934-1939, M., 2003.
  55. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 15, p. 108, d. 47, l. 32-33; op. 103, d. 1, l. 95-96.
  56. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 19, p. 164, d. 814, l. 82-83.
  57. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 16, p. 114, d. 1, l. 31-32, 43, 56-60; DVP, t. XIX, s. 98-99; AVP RF, f. 05, op. 16, p. 118, d. 44, l. 19-21.
  58. N880/20/38, FO 371 20339; Carley M.J. A Fearful Concatenation of Circumstances': The Anglo-Soviet Rapprochement, 1934-1936. -Contemporary European History, v. 5, no. 1 (1996), r. 29-69.
  59. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 20, p. 167, d. 828, l. 79-84; f. 0136, op. 20, p. 167, d. 828, l. 84-79, 120-124.
  60. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 16, p. 116, d. 22, l. 38-39; Na prieme u Stalina, s. 191-193.
  61. Carley M.J. Caught in a Cleft-Stick: Soviet Diplomacy and the Spanish Civil War. -The International Context of the Spanish Civil War. Cambridge, 2009, r. 151-180.
  62. DDF, 2e, t. III, r. 329-331.
  63. AMAE (Arhiva Ministerului Afacerilor Externe, Bucharest), fond 71 (1920-1944), URSS, v. 84, ff. 4-5; DDF, 2e, t. III, 552-553, 570-571; SRO, t. II, s. 110-111.
  64. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 20, p. 167, d. 828, l. 172-175.
  65. AVP RF, l. 23-24.
  66. "Notes on the Attitude of the French General Staff towards the Franco-Soviet Pact", F. G. Beaumont Nesbitt (oktyabr', tochnee ne datirovano), C7262/92/62, FO 371 19880.
  67. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 20, p. 167, d. 828, l. 185-189.
  68. AVP RF, op. 21, p. 169, d. 837, l. 13-14; Archives nationales, Paris, entrees du 8 fevr. et du 8 mars 1937, Papiers Schweisguth, 351AP/3.
  69. DVP, t. XIX, s. 428-429; C3620/532/38, FO 371 20702; C3685/532/62, ibid.; C3910/532/62, ibid. Sm.: Jansen S. Pierre Cot. Un antifasciste radical. Paris, 2002, r. 294-307.
  70. Carley M.J. A Soviet Eye on France from the rue de Grenelle in Paris, 1924-1940. -Diplomacy & Statecraft, v. 17, no. 2 (2006), p. 322-327.
  71. C8880/532/62, FO 371 20702.
  72. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 21, p. 169, d. 837, l. 4-7; f. 05, op. 17, p. 135, d. 109, l. 35.
  73. AVP RF, f. 0138, op. 18, p. 126, d. 1, l. 28-31, 35-36.
  74. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 17, p. 128, d. 24, l. 58-61; f. 0136, op. 21, p. 109, d. 839, l. 3-4.
  75. Carley M.J. Episodes from the Early Cold War, Franco-Soviet Relations, 1917-1927. -Europe-Asia Studies, v. 57, no. 7, 2000, p. 1278; Carley M.J. Soviet Eye, p. 319-320; AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 21, p. 169, d. 839, l. 12-19; op. 20, p. 167, d. 828, l. 180-182; Lacroix-Riz A. Le choix de la defaite. Les elites francaises dans les annees 1930. Paris, 2006, p. 173-178.
  76. Vidal G. Le PCF et la defense nationale a l'epoque du Front populaire (1934-1939). -Guerres mondiales et confl its contemporains, № 215 (2004), p. 47-73.
  77. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 21, p. 169, d. 837, l. 19-22; DDF, 2e, t. VII, r. 433-435.
  78. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, p. 140, d. 26, l. 1-4.
  79. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 21, p. 169, d. 839, l. 53-58; f. 05, op. 17, p. 128, d. 24, l. 70-71, DIMS, s. 19-20
  80. Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. 1, s. 190-195; AMAE, fond 71/France, v. 3, fol. 6.
  81. Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. 1, s. 165.
  82. AVP RF, f. 011, op. 1, p. 8, d. 76, l. 180-186; f. 0136, op. 21, p. 169, d. 839, l. 59-63.
  83. AVP RF, f. 011, op. 2, p. 17, d. 165, l. 10-12.
  84. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, p. 140, d. 26, l. 10-13.
  85. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 22, p. 172, d. 863, l. 75-78; DDF, 2e, t. VIII, p. 772-774; t. VII, p. 550-552.
  86. AVP RF, f. 0138, op. 19, p. 128, d. 1, l. 13-15.
  87. DVP, t. XXI, s. 126-127; DDF, 2e, t. VIII, p. 824-831; AMAE, fond 71/France, v. 3, ff. 27-29.
  88. AVP RF, f. 011, op. 2, d. 17, p. 11, l. 28-29.
  89. Cadogan's minute, 17 March 1938, C1935/95/62, FO 371 21626.
  90. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, d. 149, p. 166, l. 4-7; f. 05, op. 18, d. 148, p. 158, l. 15-19; DVP, t. XXI, s. 96-97.
  91. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, d. 148, p. 158, l. 34-36.
  92. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, d. 140, p. 26, l. 22-24.
  93. DVP, t. XXI, s. 161-164; AVP RF, f. 0138, op. 19, d. 128, p. 1, l. 23.
  94. AVP RF, f. 0138, op. 19, d. 128, p. 1, l. 25-28; op. 18, d. 140, p. 26, l. 32-33.
  95. FRUS, 1938, v. I, p. 500-504; University of Birmingham, N. Chamberlain Papers, NC18/1/1042, Chamberlain to his sister Ida, 20 March 1938.
  96. DGFP, D, v. II, p. 257-260; FRUS, 1938, v. I, p. 493-495, 500-504.
  97. DVP, t. XXI, s. 262-263; AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, p. 149, d. 166, l. 11-13; FRUS, 1938, v. I, p. 500-504; DDF, 2e, t. IX, p. 671-673; AMAE, fond 71/URSS, v. 85, ff. 217-220.
  98. AMAE, fond 71/Romania, v. 102, ff. 116, 170-171; sr.: Ragsdale H. Op. cit., p. 83-86, 148.
  99. DDF, 2e, t. IX, p. 815-816, 825-826; AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, p. 149, d. 166, l. 11-13.
  100. DGFP, D, v. II, p. 326-328.
  101. DIMS, s. 132.
  102. Carley M.J. 1939, p. 42-44.
  103. AVP RF, f. 0138, op. 19, d. 128, d. 1, l. 33-34.
  104. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, d. 149, p. 166, l. 16-18; cp. Steiner Z. Op. cit., r. 758.
  105. DDF, v. X, ff. 437-438; DVP, t. XXI, s. 387-389.
  106. Carnets secrets de Jean Zay (Paris, 1942), entree du 19 sept. 1938, p. 6.
  107. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, d. 149, p. 166, l. 24-27; cp.: Steiner Z. Op. cit., r. 759-760.
  108. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, d. 149, p. 166, l. 30-32; DDF, 2e, t. X, p. 445-448, 450-451; DVP, t. XXI, s. 402-405.
  109. AVP RF, f. 011, op. 2, d. 17, p. 165, l. 91-105.
  110. DDF, 2e, t. X, p. 467-468.
  111. DDF, 2e, t. X, p. 519-520.
  112. DIMS, s. 174-175; DDF, 2e, t. X, p. 843, 874-875.
  113. DDF, 2e, t. X, p. 840.
  114. DDF, 2e, t. X, p. 899-900.
  115. DBFP, ser. 3., v. II, p. 194, 219-220.
  116. Steiner Z. Op. cit., p. 763; "Na prieme u Stalina", s. 239; DVP, t. XXI, s. 470-471; DDF, 2e, t. X, p. 934-935.
  117. DBFP, ser. 3, v. II, p. 255-256, 269-270; Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. I, s. 251, 267-268;
  118. Carley M.J. 1939, r. 51-55.
  119. DVP, t. XXI, s. 487-488.
  120. AVP RF, f. 0138, op. 19, d. 128, p. 1, l. 45-46; DIMS, s. 215.
  121. DBFP, ser. 3, v. II, p. 309-312; DIMS, s. 211-212.
  122. DBFP, ser. 3, v. II, p. 323.
  123. Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. I, s. 270-271; AMAE, fond 71/Romania, v. 103, fol. 124; DIMS, s. 213-214; AMAE, fond 71/Little Entante, v. 29, fol. 28.
  124. DIMS, s. 235-236, 244-245; DDF, 2e, t. XI, p. 347-348; Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. I, s. 273-274; DDF, 2e, t. XI, p. 361, 394, 397-398.
  125. Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. I, s. 275-276.
  126. C10251/5302/18, FO 371 21777.
  127. DVP, t. XXI, s. 498-499; Politbyuro TsK RKP(b), s. 363-364; DVP, t. XXI, s. 500; DIMS, s. 244.
  128. DIMS, s. 240-241.
  129. Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. I, s. 276-280.
  130. Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn', 1988, № 12, s. 119-132; AVP RF, f. 0138, op. 19, d. 128, p. 1, l. 69-70.
  131. Carley M.J. Soviet Foreign Policy in the West, 1936-1941. -Europe-Asia Studies, v. 56, № 7 (2004), p. 1081-1092.
  132. DVP, t. XXI, s. 515-517; DDF, 2e, t. XI, p. 486-487, 501.
  133. Herbrand Edward, Earl de la Warr, Lord Privy Seal (Geneva), no. 52, 15 Sept. 1938, C9953/5302/18, FO 371 21776; AMAE, fond 71/Romania, v. 103, ff. 152-153; FRUS, 1938, v. I, p. 652-654; AMAE, fond 71/Romania, v. 103, fol. 61.
  134. AMAE, fond 71/spetsial'nye papki, v. 343, ff. 12, 21, 34-35.
  135. Ragsdale H. Op. cit., p. 111-126.
  136. DIMS, s. 265; DDF, 2e, t. XI, p. 446-447.
  137. AVP RF, f. 0138, op. 19, d. 128, p. 1, l. 71-72; DIMS, s. 204-205.
  138. Meltz R. Alexis Leger, dit Saint-John Perse. Paris, 2008, p. 518-526; Carnets secrets de Jean Zay, entrees des 21-22 sept. 1938, p. 7-9.
  139. Coulondre, nos. 718-720, 724-727, 23, 24, & 27 sept. 1938; Bonnet a Coulondre, no. 555, 28 sept. 1938, MAE, Bureau du chiffre, Telegrammes a l'arrivee de Moscou, janvier 1938 -23 aout 1939; AMAE, fond 71/spetsial'nye papki, v. 343, ff. 36-38, DBFP, ser. 3, v. II, p. 489.
  140. DBFP, ser. 3, v. II, p. 509-510; DVP, t. XXI, s. 735, prim. 149, s. 510.
  141. DIMS, s. 284; Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. I, s. 280-283.
  142. DBFP, ser. 3, v. II, p. 510, 535, 543-544.
  143. Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. I, s. 283-284; AMAE, fond 71/special fi les, v. 343, fol. 27; DBFP, ser. 3, v. II, p. 509-510; FRUS, 1938, v. I, p. 620-621.
  144. Majskij I.M. Dnevnik, kn. I, s. 284-285. Cr.: DBFP, ser. 3, v. II, p. 520-541, 575-576.
  145. DBFP, ser. 3, v. II, p. 588.
  146. DIMS, s. 326-327; AMAE, fond 71/Malaya Antanta, v. 29, fol. 116.
  147. Meltz R. Op. cit., r. 525.
  148. Pathe Gazette, URL: www.britishpathe.com/record.php?id-20737.
  149. Pathe Gazette, URL: www.britishpathe.com/record.php?id-50545.
  150. DVP, t. XXI, s. 555-556; C11379/5302/18, FO 371 21778; Pathe Gazette, URL: http://www. britishpathe.com/record.php?id-20746
  151. Imeyutsya v vidu slova Dalad'e o tom, chto Frantsiya budet opozorena, esli ne vstupitsya za Chekhoslovakiyu v sluchae napadeniya na nee Germanii (sm. vyshe). -Prim. red.
  152. AVP RF, f. 0136, op. 22, d. 172, p. 863, l. 9-10.
  153. Blagodaryu prof. R. Dzhonsona iz Universiteta Toronto za to, chto on obratil moe vnimanie na ehtot sovetskij otvet.
  154. The Diaries of Sir Robert Bruce Lockhart, 1915-1946. London, 1973, v. I, p. 399, 402; AMAE, fond 71/Romania, v. 259, ff. 96-100; FRUS, 1938, v. I, p. 667-669.
  155. AVP RF, f. 011, op. 2, d. 17, p. 165, l. 201-192; d. 11, p. 17, l. 76-83; op. 18, d. 148, p. 158, l. 75-76; d. 72, p. 165, l. 222-229, 238-255.
  156. AVP RF, f. 05, op. 18, d. 148, p. 158, l. 88-90.
  157. Tam zhe, l. 100-103.
  158. Carley M.J. 1939, ch. 4.
  159. Khlevniuk O.V. Master of the House: Stalin and His Inner Circle. New Haven, 2009, r. 251.       
  160. Na prieme u Stalina, s. 228-239.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate